Draw a trip's three sections as text tabs in the page, not a split view or the system tab bar
Amends ADR-0070.
Decision
Draw a trip's three sections, Explore, Trip and Timeline, as plain words in the page, and switch between them there. At regular width they sit centred in a header row between the way back to the trips list and the trip's actions, over an ink double rule. At compact width they sit in a ruled strip at the bottom, driving the same selection as before, with the system tab bar hidden. Pushed screens keep the system navigation bar and its back button.
Why
The app's redesign draws the trip as a printed page, with rules, words and one accent colour. The split view's source-list sidebar and the system tab bar each bring their own material, icons, selection pill and glass capsule, which puts a second visual language on every screen of the trip. Three sections do not need a sidebar's room, and on the Mac a sidebar spent a third of the window on three words. Logic is untouched: the tabs set the same selection, and each section's content is the same shared view on both platforms, so ADR-0070's rule that only presentation differs still holds.
Rejected alternatives
- Keep the
NavigationSplitViewsidebar at regular width and the system tab bar at compact width (ADR-0070). Native and free, but it draws the trip's chrome in the system's look, and the redesign's mock-ups have no place for either. - Style the system tab bar. It cannot be made into plain words on a rule; it stays a floating glass capsule.
Consequences
The compact layout changes, which ADR-0070 said it should not. The tab strip is ours to maintain: it has to keep clear of the keyboard and the home indicator and cap its text size, which the system bar did for free. The tab identifiers the end-to-end flows tap now sit on these words.